Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4 Journals Explained: How to Read Journal Quartiles and Rankings
journal quartilesQ1 journalsScimagojournal metricsacademic publishing

Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4 Journals Explained: How to Read Journal Quartiles and Rankings

SScholarly Nexus Editorial Team
2026-11-17
6 min read

Learn what Q1–Q4 journal quartiles mean, why rankings differ, and how to verify a journal’s database, metric, category, and year.

Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4 describe a journal’s position within a particular subject category and ranking system. This guide explains what quartiles mean, why the same journal can receive different quartiles, and how to verify the right result before using a ranking for a submission, promotion review, grant report, or research shortlist.

Overview

A journal quartile ranking divides journals in a subject category into four groups. Q1 generally represents the highest-ranked group, followed by Q2, Q3, and Q4. In simple terms, a Q1 journal is positioned near the top of its category, while a Q4 journal is positioned in the lowest group of that same category.

That description is useful, but incomplete. A quartile is not a universal label attached permanently to a journal. It depends on several details:

  • The database: For example, Journal Citation Reports and SCImago Journal & Country Rank use different systems and data sources.
  • The metric: A ranking may be based on Journal Impact Factor, Journal Citation Indicator, CiteScore, SJR, or another measure.
  • The subject category: A journal can be placed in more than one category, with a different position in each.
  • The ranking year: Quartiles can change as citation data, journal coverage, category membership, and calculation methods change.

For this reason, “Q1 journal” is not enough information for a reliable academic record. A useful record should state the database, metric, category, ranking year, and the date on which the information was checked.

Quartiles are also only one part of journal quality assessment. They do not replace checking a journal’s aims and scope, peer-review process, editorial information, publication ethics, indexing status, access model, or publication charges. Use a ranking as evidence to interpret, not as an automatic guarantee of suitability or research quality.

Checklist by scenario

Before choosing a journal for submission

  1. Confirm that the journal publishes research in your precise subject area, not merely a neighboring discipline.
  2. Record the journal’s exact title, ISSN or eISSN, and publisher. These details help prevent confusion with similarly named journals.
  3. Choose the ranking system that your institution, funder, department, or evaluation process recognizes.
  4. Check every relevant subject category. A journal may be Q1 in one category and Q2 or Q3 in another.
  5. Write down the ranking year and the metric behind the quartile.
  6. Compare the result with the journal’s current website and official database record, while treating promotional claims as claims to verify.

Journal fit should come before prestige. A highly ranked journal outside your article’s scope may be a weaker choice than a well-matched journal with a different ranking. For a wider selection process, use the journal fit checklist alongside your ranking notes.

When a policy asks for a Q1 or Q2 journal

  1. Identify whether the policy specifies Web of Science, Journal Citation Reports, Scopus, SCImago, CiteScore, or another source.
  2. Check whether it requires a quartile for the publication year, submission year, acceptance year, or reporting year.
  3. Ask whether the policy accepts the best category, the lowest category, or a designated subject category.
  4. Save a dated record, screenshot, export, or official report where permitted by the database terms.
  5. Do not substitute a Q1 result from one database when the policy names another.

If the wording is unclear, obtain written clarification before submission or reporting. A ranking mismatch discovered after publication can be difficult to correct.

When comparing journals in different disciplines

Quartiles are most meaningful within a defined category. Citation behavior differs between fields, so comparing a Q1 journal in one discipline directly with a Q1 journal in another does not necessarily establish that they have identical influence, audience, selectivity, or editorial standards. Use quartiles to compare plausible journals within the same field and evaluation framework, then consider readership, methods, article types, review timelines, open access terms, and APCs.

When building a research journal list

Create a spreadsheet with columns for journal title, ISSN, publisher, scope, database, metric, category, quartile, ranking year, access model, APC information, and verification date. This makes it easier to distinguish a verified ranking from an unconfirmed claim and to update the list during future planning cycles. The journal monitoring workflow can help organize these checks.

What to double-check

System or termWhat it representsWhat to verify
Journal Citation ReportsA Clarivate research evaluation resource that includes journal-level metrics and category rankings.The exact edition or year, category, metric, and quartile displayed for the journal.
Journal Impact FactorA journal-level citation metric presented in Journal Citation Reports.Whether the requested quartile is specifically the Journal Impact Factor quartile, rather than another Web of Science metric.
ScopusA bibliographic and abstract database with journal metrics and coverage information.Whether the journal is currently covered, the relevant metric and year, and the category used.
CiteScore percentileA percentile position within a Scopus subject category, often used to interpret relative standing.Do not automatically treat a percentile as identical to a quartile. Confirm how the required institution converts or labels it.
SCImago Journal & Country RankA public journal-ranking portal using Scopus data and indicators including SJR.The SJR year, subject area, category, quartile, and journal identity. SCImago results should not be presented as Journal Citation Reports results.

These systems answer related but different questions. A journal can be indexed in both Web of Science and Scopus yet have different quartiles because the databases use different coverage, categories, metrics, and calculation rules. Likewise, its SCImago quartile may not match its Journal Citation Reports quartile. The difference is not automatically an error; it is a sign that the result needs to be labeled precisely.

Also check the journal’s identity. Search by ISSN where possible, compare the publisher and journal title, and be cautious if a website displays a badge without naming the database, metric, category, or year. For a separate indexing check, consult how to verify Scopus and Web of Science coverage.

Common mistakes

  • Treating Q1 as a permanent status: Quartiles can move from year to year. Always record the applicable year.
  • Using “Q1” without naming the database: A reader cannot reproduce or assess an unlabeled ranking.
  • Assuming every metric has the same quartile: Journal Impact Factor, CiteScore, SJR, and other indicators are not interchangeable.
  • Ignoring subject categories: The same journal may rank differently in separate categories.
  • Confusing indexing with ranking: Inclusion in a database does not by itself mean that a journal is Q1, peer-reviewed to a particular standard, or suitable for your paper.
  • Relying on third-party lists without checking the source: Lists can become outdated or omit the category and ranking year.
  • Choosing a journal by quartile alone: Scope, article type, audience, ethics, editorial transparency, APCs, and peer-review expectations still matter.

Be especially careful with “fast publishing,” “top journal,” or “guaranteed acceptance” language. These phrases do not establish a quartile or demonstrate legitimate indexing. Review the journal’s submission information, policies, and records independently.

When to revisit

Recheck a journal quartile whenever you are about to submit a manuscript, complete an annual research report, prepare a promotion or graduation file, apply for funding, or update a department journal list. Revisit it after a new ranking release, a database coverage change, a journal title or publisher change, or an update to your institution’s evaluation rules.

Before acting, complete this short final checklist:

  1. Have I confirmed the journal’s exact identity and ISSN?
  2. Am I using the database required by my institution or funder?
  3. Have I recorded the metric, subject category, quartile, and ranking year?
  4. Could the journal have a different result in another category or database?
  5. Have I checked scope, peer review, indexing, ethics, access model, and APC information separately?
  6. Have I saved the verification date and supporting record?

That record turns a vague claim such as “this is a Q1 journal” into a defensible statement: the journal was Q1 in a named category, according to a named system and metric, for a specified year. When rankings change, update the record rather than silently replacing the older result. For related decisions, compare journal acceptance rates and peer-review timelines, and review the journal’s current submission requirements before sending your manuscript.

Related Topics

#journal quartiles#Q1 journals#Scimago#journal metrics#academic publishing
S

Scholarly Nexus Editorial Team

Academic Publishing Editor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.