A complete manuscript formatting checklist can prevent avoidable delays at submission. Use this guide to prepare blinded and unblinded files, standardize text, check figures and tables, organize supplementary material, and confirm that every required declaration is ready before uploading your paper.
Overview
Manuscript submission requirements vary by journal, article type, publisher, and submission platform. A research article may require a main document, a separate title page, individual figure files, supplementary data, reporting checklists, and declarations. A review, short communication, case report, or registered report may use a different structure.
Start with the journal’s current author instructions rather than relying on a previous submission or a generic template. Confirm the requirements immediately before uploading, especially after a manuscript transfer, revision, resubmission, or change of journal. The checklist below is a preparation framework; the journal’s instructions take priority when they differ.
| Item | What to prepare | What to verify |
|---|---|---|
| Title page | Title, authors, affiliations, corresponding author, acknowledgments, and declarations as requested | Whether it must be separate from the blinded manuscript |
| Main manuscript | Anonymous text, abstract, keywords, main sections, references, tables, and figure legends | Word limit, article structure, and anonymization rules |
| Figures | Correct file type, numbering, captions or legends, and readable labels | Resolution, color, size, and upload limits |
| Tables | Editable tables with titles, notes, units, and citations | Placement, numbering, and whether tables must be separate |
| Supplementary files | Datasets, protocols, appendices, code, checklists, or extended methods | Allowed formats, descriptions, and public-access expectations |
Checklist by scenario
For a new submission
- Record the journal’s required article type, word count, abstract format, keyword limit, and reference style.
- Check whether the journal requests a single combined file or separate uploads for the manuscript, title page, figures, tables, and supplementary material.
- Prepare an unblinded title page containing the full title, author names, institutional affiliations, corresponding-author contact details, acknowledgments, funding statement, conflict-of-interest statement, ethics information, data-availability statement, and other required declarations.
- Prepare a blinded manuscript if the journal uses anonymized peer review. Remove names, affiliations, acknowledgments, grant identifiers, institutional references, file metadata, and self-identifying language where instructed.
- Use the required manuscript order. A common sequence is title or abstract, keywords, main text, references, tables, figure legends, and appendices, but the journal may specify another order.
- Confirm that every citation in the text appears in the reference list and that every reference-list entry is cited where required.
- Upload a cover letter only if requested or useful for the journal’s process. Keep it consistent with the manuscript title, article type, authorship, and disclosures.
For double-anonymous or blinded review
- Create separate files with clear names such as Manuscript_Blinded and Title_Page_Unblinded.
- Inspect the document properties and remove author names, organization names, comments, tracked changes, and hidden revision history.
- Replace self-references with neutral wording only when the journal requires it; do not remove necessary evidence from the scholarly record.
- Check figures, supplementary files, dataset labels, file names, and image metadata for identifying information.
- Follow the journal’s instructions for ethics approvals, trial registration, locations, or institutional descriptions. Blinding should not compromise required transparency.
For a revision or resubmission
- Download the latest author instructions again. A revision may use the same file structure as the original submission, but this should not be assumed.
- Mark changes as requested, using tracked changes, highlighted text, or a clean and marked version.
- Prepare a point-by-point response file that identifies each reviewer comment, gives the response, and states the exact location of changes. See the point-by-point reviewer response guide for a reusable structure.
- Recheck references, tables, figures, supplementary files, and declarations after every substantive revision.
- Remove obsolete files from the upload package so that editors do not mistake an earlier version for the final one.
For a manuscript transfer or a new journal
- Do not assume that a transfer carries over formatting, declarations, or supplementary files correctly.
- Compare the new journal’s aims, scope, article type, word limit, abstract structure, citation style, and file requirements.
- Review the journal’s access model and publication-cost information separately from formatting. The guide to APCs, waivers, and funding can help organize that comparison.
- Keep a new version of the file package and preserve the submitted version for your records.
What to double-check
Text, headings, fonts, and spacing
Use a readable, consistent font and apply document styles rather than manually formatting every heading. Check the journal’s instructions for font, line spacing, margins, page numbering, heading levels, and line numbering. If no specific font is required, consistency is more important than decorative design. Keep headings parallel in structure, define abbreviations at first use, and ensure that equations, symbols, and special characters display correctly after conversion to PDF.
Confirm the total word count using the journal’s definition. Some journals exclude references, tables, captions, or supplementary material; others count them. Check the abstract separately, including its format and maximum length. For guidance on abstract structure, compare the structured abstract checklist with the journal’s own requirements.
Figures and tables
Number figures and tables in the order they are first mentioned. Make every figure and table understandable without forcing the reader to search through the text. Include descriptive titles or legends, define abbreviations, provide measurement units, and identify statistical notation. Check that labels remain readable at the expected publication size.
Do not embed a low-quality screenshot when the journal requests an editable or high-resolution file. Confirm accepted formats, color requirements, maximum file size, resolution, and whether composite figures should be uploaded as one file or as separate panels. For tables, use an editable table structure rather than spaces or tabs. Check decimal places, totals, sample sizes, and consistency with the results section.
Supplementary material and declarations
Give each supplementary file a clear name and a short description. Check whether the journal wants supplementary figures and tables numbered separately, whether data or code should be deposited elsewhere, and whether a reporting checklist is required for your study design. Confirm that links, datasets, scripts, and appendices open correctly and contain no accidental personal or confidential information.
Declarations commonly include funding, conflicts of interest, ethics approval, consent, author contributions, data availability, and acknowledgments. Include only statements that apply, but do not omit a required declaration. If publication metadata needs cleaning before reporting or submission, use the DOI and metadata verification workflow.
Common mistakes
- Using an old template: Templates and submission systems can change. Treat the official instructions as the controlling document.
- Mixing blinded and unblinded content: Acknowledgments, affiliations, funding identifiers, and document metadata can reveal authors.
- Submitting a PDF when editable files are required: Check the permitted file type for each component before uploading.
- Inconsistent numbering: Compare all in-text citations with figure, table, section, and reference numbering after the final edit.
- Leaving tracked changes or comments: Accept or reject revisions, delete comments, and inspect the clean file before submission.
- Ignoring file names: Use short, descriptive names without confusing versions, personal data, or unsupported symbols.
- Formatting before checking scope: A carefully formatted manuscript is still unsuitable if its article type and subject do not match the journal.
- Assuming a successful upload means a complete submission: Review the generated PDF, answer every required form question, and confirm that the submission status indicates completion.
When to revisit
Use this checklist before every new submission, revision, resubmission, manuscript transfer, and coauthor handoff. Recheck it before seasonal planning cycles if your research group prepares several papers at once. It is also worth revisiting whenever a publisher changes its submission platform, a journal updates its author instructions, a reporting guideline becomes relevant to your study design, or your team adopts a new reference manager or document workflow.
For a practical final pass, assign one person to check content and another to check files. Then complete these five actions:
- Save the current author instructions and record the date checked.
- Compare the required upload list with the files in your submission folder.
- Open the blinded manuscript, title page, figures, tables, and supplementary files independently.
- Inspect the generated submission PDF and all declarations for accuracy.
- Archive the submitted package, response letter, and confirmation details in a clearly named project folder.
This workflow does not replace careful editing or journal-specific guidance, but it makes manuscript file preparation repeatable. A short, documented check before upload can prevent avoidable technical queries and preserve time for the substantive parts of scholarly publishing.