How to Check for Retractions, Corrections, and Expressions of Concern Before Citing a Paper
retractionsresearch integritycitation checkingCrossmarkliterature review

How to Check for Retractions, Corrections, and Expressions of Concern Before Citing a Paper

SScholarly Nexus Editorial Team
2026-11-20
7 min read

Learn how to check publisher pages, Crossmark, indexing records, and retraction databases before citing a research paper.

Before citing a research paper, check more than its title and DOI. This practical workflow shows how to find retractions, corrections, and expressions of concern across the publisher page, Crossmark, indexing records, and retraction databases, then decide whether the paper can be cited and how its status should be described.

Overview

A paper’s publication status can change after it first appears in a journal. A publisher may issue a correction, publish an editorial notice, add an expression of concern, or retract the article altogether. These notices may not be visible in an exported reference list, a PDF saved months earlier, or a citation generated by a reference manager.

That is why a retraction check should be part of normal research practice. It is especially important when preparing a systematic review, thesis chapter, grant report, manuscript bibliography, evidence summary, or major policy document. The goal is not to treat every post-publication notice as proof that an article is unusable. The goal is to identify the notice, understand what it changes, and represent the paper accurately.

Use the article’s DOI as the main identifier, but do not rely on the DOI alone. A DOI identifies a publication record; it does not guarantee that the record is still valid as evidence. The most reliable approach is to compare the publisher’s current article page with at least one independent discovery or indexing source.

What to track

1. The article’s core identifiers

Record the DOI, article title, author list, journal, publication year, volume, issue, and page or article number. Begin with a DOI lookup through the publisher or Crossref search. Compare the returned metadata with the paper you have in hand. Small differences can reveal that you are looking at a commentary, protocol, conference item, or correction rather than the original research article.

For a repeatable audit, keep a simple spreadsheet with columns for DOI, publisher URL, date checked, status, notice URL, database checked, and notes. This creates an audit trail and makes it easier to repeat the check before submission.

2. The publisher’s article page

Open the current version of the article on the journal’s website. Look for labels such as retracted, corrected, expression of concern, updated, or amended. Also inspect links near the title, abstract, PDF, article history, and supplementary files. Publishers use different terminology and page designs, so search within the page for terms such as retraction, correction, concern, notice, or editorial.

Read the notice itself rather than relying on a colored banner or a short status label. A notice should normally indicate which article it concerns and explain the reason or scope of the post-publication action. Check whether the notice applies to the entire article, a figure, a table, a data set, a method, or a specific bibliographic detail.

3. Crossmark or another update indicator

If the article displays a Crossmark button, select it to view information about the document’s current status and any updates recorded by the participating publisher. Crossmark can help identify corrections, retractions, and other changes associated with the publication record. Its absence is not evidence that an article has no notice; not every article or publisher presents updates through the same service.

When a PDF is downloaded or shared, check the live publisher record again. A locally stored file may not display a later correction or retraction notice.

4. Indexing and retraction databases

Search the DOI and title in the relevant indexing service for your field. Some records link to corrections or retractions, while others may show separate records for the original article and its notice. Field-specific databases can be useful, but their update timing and coverage can differ from the publisher’s record.

You can also search a recognized retraction database, such as the Retraction Watch Database, where available and appropriate for your work. Treat database results as an additional check, not a substitute for reading the publisher’s notice. If records conflict, preserve the conflicting links and contact the journal or database provider before finalizing an important evidence synthesis.

5. The meaning of the notice

NoticeWhat it generally meansHow to handle the paper
Correction or erratumThe publisher has identified and documented an error or change in the published record. The effect may be minor or may affect interpretation.Read the notice and use the corrected version where possible. Explain the correction if it affects your analysis, quotation, table, or conclusion.
Expression of concernThe journal has raised a formal concern while an investigation or assessment is unresolved.Do not treat the article as ordinary uncontested evidence. Recheck its status, disclose the concern, and seek independent support for important claims.
RetractionThe journal has withdrawn the article from the reliable scholarly record because of problems that affect its validity, integrity, or publication status.Do not use the article as ordinary supporting evidence. If it is necessary to discuss the history of a finding or a retraction, cite it clearly as retracted and cite the retraction notice.
Retraction and replacement or revised versionThe original record has been withdrawn and a replacement or revised publication may be available.Read the relationship between the records. Cite the valid version for current evidence and identify the original only when the publication history matters.

Cadence and checkpoints

Use a two-stage schedule. First, check every paper when it enters a high-stakes working bibliography. Second, repeat the check shortly before submission, publication, reporting, or public release. A paper collected during an early literature search may receive a notice while your project is underway.

  1. At discovery: Save the DOI and publisher URL, confirm the basic metadata, and note any visible status label.
  2. At evidence extraction: Read the current article page and check Crossmark or the publisher’s update information. Record the date and status in your project log.
  3. Before drafting: Recheck papers that support central claims, key methods, sample-size assumptions, or major conclusions.
  4. Before submission: Run the DOI list through the publisher pages and relevant indexing or retraction databases. Pay particular attention to articles cited repeatedly.
  5. After publication: For living reviews, guidelines, or regularly updated reports, schedule a quarterly or other project-appropriate review of the evidence base.

A monthly check may be reasonable for an active evidence-monitoring project; a quarterly check may be sufficient for a stable teaching bibliography. The right interval depends on how quickly the field changes and how much a status change would affect your conclusions.

How to interpret changes

Do not make a binary decision based only on the presence of a notice. Start by asking what changed and which part of your work depends on the paper. A typographical correction in an author affiliation is different from a correction to a denominator, study group, statistical result, or figure. In each case, compare the notice with the version you used.

For a correction, update quotations, page references, extracted values, and interpretations. If the correction does not affect your use of the article, retain it in the bibliography but note that you checked the notice when maintaining an internal audit trail.

For an expression of concern, pause before presenting the findings as settled. Look for corroborating studies and state the concern near the relevant claim. An expression of concern is not necessarily a final finding of misconduct or invalidity, but it is a material signal that readers should know about.

For a retraction, remove the paper from ordinary evidence support unless your purpose is specifically to analyze the retracted work, publication ethics, or the history of a research claim. If you must mention it, label it as retracted and cite the notice. Do not silently replace a retracted article with a different paper while leaving the original citation in place.

When status information conflicts, give priority to the current publisher notice for the article’s formal publication status, then document the disagreement and seek clarification. Indexing records can lag, contain duplicate records, or display notices differently.

When to revisit

Revisit this workflow whenever a literature review is substantially updated, a manuscript moves toward submission, or a report is converted into a new edition. Set a calendar reminder for monthly or quarterly checks if your project depends on a changing evidence base. Also repeat the process when a coauthor, reader, editor, or database flags a paper.

Review the tools themselves at least every six months. Publisher terminology, database links, Crossmark displays, indexing coverage, and retraction-database interfaces can change. Confirm that your spreadsheet still captures the DOI, date checked, notice type, source link, and action taken.

For a practical final audit, select every reference that supports a major conclusion and complete this sequence: open the DOI, visit the publisher page, read any notice, check the update indicator, compare an indexing or retraction record, and record the result. Then revise the citation or surrounding prose where necessary. For broader reference-management guidance, see the DOI and publication metadata verification workflow and the journal monitoring workflow and spreadsheet template. A short, dated status check can prevent an outdated citation from weakening an otherwise careful piece of research.

Related Topics

#retractions#research integrity#citation checking#Crossmark#literature review
S

Scholarly Nexus Editorial Team

Academic Publishing Editors

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.