Comparing journals is not simply a matter of finding the shortest advertised review time or the highest reported acceptance rate. This guide shows how to evaluate journal acceptance rates, first-decision times, revision periods, and publication lead times using clearly labeled evidence, then turn those observations into a realistic submission schedule.
Overview
A journal’s publication timeline contains several different intervals. Treating them as one number can create unrealistic expectations and make two journals appear easier to compare than they really are.
For example, time to first decision may include an editorial screening decision, a desk rejection, or a decision after external peer review, depending on how the journal defines and reports it. The period after a revise-and-resubmit decision is usually separate. So is the time between acceptance and online publication. An acceptance rate may also cover a particular year, article type, submission route, or editorial stage rather than every manuscript received.
The most useful comparison therefore combines four questions:
- How selective does the journal appear to be, and what exactly does its acceptance figure measure?
- How long does the journal report taking to reach an initial decision?
- How much additional time may be needed for revisions and a final decision?
- What happens after acceptance, including copyediting, proof review, and publication?
Use the journal’s official website, submission system, author instructions, and editorial policies as your primary record. Author experiences can add context, but they should be labeled as anecdotal and dated rather than treated as a representative statistic. For broader submission planning, see How to Choose the Right Journal for Your Research and What Happens After Journal Submission?.
What to track
1. Acceptance rate and its definition
Record the acceptance rate only when the journal or publisher explains what the figure represents. Note the reporting period, article types included, geographic or disciplinary scope if stated, and whether the rate refers to all submissions or a later editorial stage.
A bare percentage is weak evidence. A better entry might say: “Publisher-reported acceptance rate; year stated; definition not fully explained; checked on [date].” If no rate is published, record “not reported” rather than estimating it from reputation, ranking, or isolated author accounts. An unpublished acceptance rate is not evidence that a journal is either highly selective or easy to enter.
2. First-decision time
Capture the journal’s exact terminology. Possible labels include time to first decision, initial decision, first editorial decision, or decision after review. These terms may not be interchangeable.
Also record whether the journal distinguishes between a desk decision and a decision after peer review. If the policy is unclear, write that limitation in your worksheet. A short first-decision time may reflect efficient editorial screening, not necessarily a completed external review.
3. Peer-review timeline
Look for information about the time from submission to reviewer invitation, reviewer assignment, review completion, or a decision after external review. Journals may report one of these stages, several, or none.
Do not convert a stated average into a guaranteed deadline. Reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, editor workload, holidays, and the need to recruit additional reviewers can affect an individual submission. The most responsible comparison uses language such as “reported interval” or “planning estimate,” not “promised turnaround.”
4. Revision and resubmission time
Track the author’s revision deadline, the expected time for a revised manuscript to be assessed, and whether the journal commonly sends revisions back to the original reviewers. These details may appear in decision letters or editorial policies rather than on a public metrics page.
For your own plan, estimate the work involved in addressing reviewer comments. A minor revision and a revision requiring new analysis should not receive the same calendar allowance. Keep a separate record of the date the decision arrived, the date the revision was submitted, and the date of the next decision.
5. Acceptance-to-publication time
Measure the post-acceptance interval separately. It may include production checks, copyediting, typesetting, author proof corrections, licensing, and online publication. A journal that reviews quickly may still have a longer production queue, while another may publish accepted articles in stages.
Check whether the journal distinguishes online publication from issue assignment. If your deadline depends on a citable article, confirm which publication event matters for your institution, funder, examination, or promotion requirements.
Comparison worksheet
| Variable | What to record | Evidence label | Planning use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acceptance rate | Figure, reporting period, definition, article types | Publisher-reported or not reported | Assess selectivity cautiously |
| First decision | Exact term and stated interval | Editorial policy or submission system | Estimate the first response |
| External review | Review-stage interval, if available | Publisher-reported or author-reported | Estimate review uncertainty |
| Revision | Deadline and likely review route | Decision letter or policy | Reserve author work time |
| Publication | Acceptance-to-online and issue timing | Publisher-reported or observed | Plan for visibility or formal publication |
For each entry, add the URL, access date, exact wording, and a confidence note. This makes the comparison auditable when a journal changes its website or reporting method.
Cadence and checkpoints
Review your shortlist at three useful points: before submission, while a manuscript is under review, and after a decision. A monthly or quarterly check is appropriate for a time-sensitive project, while a check before each new submission may be enough for less urgent work.
Before submission
- Save the journal’s current author guidelines and metrics page.
- Record the definitions attached to every timeline or acceptance figure.
- Check manuscript type, word limit, formatting, peer-review model, and submission requirements.
- Confirm any dates that matter to you, such as a graduation, grant report, conference, or hiring review.
- Build a schedule with a buffer rather than working backward from the most optimistic interval.
Before uploading, use a research paper formatting checklist. A complete submission can reduce avoidable administrative delays, although it cannot guarantee a faster decision.
During review
Record the submission date, manuscript ID, status changes, editorial messages, reviewer invitations if visible, and any request for additional information. Status labels vary between systems, so interpret them using the journal’s own guidance rather than assuming that a label has a universal meaning.
If the stated interval has passed substantially, send a concise, courteous inquiry through the channel specified by the journal. Include the manuscript ID, title, submission date, and a neutral request for a status update. Avoid repeated messages at short intervals.
After a decision
Update the actual dates for first decision, revision submission, subsequent decision, acceptance, and publication. These observations are more useful for your future planning than an isolated online claim, but they still describe one manuscript rather than the journal as a whole.
How to interpret changes
When a journal’s reported numbers change, first check whether the measurement changed. A new label, reporting period, article mix, or website design can make a figure look different without showing a clear change in editorial performance.
Separate publisher-reported data from author-reported experience. The former may be more systematic but can be narrowly defined. The latter can reveal practical details, such as long periods between status updates, but may reflect unusual manuscripts, selective memory, or a small number of cases.
Interpret acceptance rates as one factor in journal fit, not as a quality score. A high rate does not prove weak peer review, and a low rate does not prove that a manuscript will receive useful feedback. Scope, readership, editorial standards, indexing requirements, open access terms, and ethical policies may matter more to the success of a particular submission.
Also distinguish delay from rejection. A long review period does not imply that acceptance is more likely, and a rapid decision does not by itself indicate poor editorial practice. Use the evidence to plan time and communication, not to predict an individual outcome.
Keep the comparison current alongside other journal checks. The workflow in How to Monitor a Journal’s Indexing, Metrics, and APCs can help you track related changes without relying on a single metric.
When to revisit
Revisit your journal comparison before every new manuscript submission and whenever your publication deadline changes. For an active shortlist, review the recorded pages monthly or quarterly. Refresh it immediately when a journal changes its submission system, author guidelines, editorial policy, publication model, or terminology for decision times.
At each review, check five items:
- Has the acceptance-rate reporting period or definition changed?
- Does the journal now separate editorial decisions from decisions after peer review?
- Have stated review or production intervals been removed, renamed, or qualified?
- Has the manuscript type or peer-review process changed?
- Does the updated schedule still fit your deadline and revision capacity?
Finally, create a realistic calendar using a range rather than a single promised date. Include time for editorial screening, external review, at least one revision cycle, author response, production, and unexpected delay. Save the evidence with the date checked, then update the actual outcome when the manuscript moves forward. This simple record turns a vague question, “How long does this journal take?”, into a repeatable journal acceptance rate comparison and a more defensible publication plan.